Feel free to contribute on burning issues concerning the armed forces. Contributions would be acknowledged - Use the 'Comments' tab or email navdeepsingh.india[at]gmail.com. No operational/business/commercial matters to be discussed please. Legal advice/litigation related issues would strictly NOT be published or discussed or entertained. Information on this blog is opinion based and is neither official nor in the form of an advice. This is a pro bono online journal in public service related to issues, policies and benefits, and the idea behind it is to educate and not to create controversy or to incite. Be soft in your language, respect Copyrights.

Monday, September 20, 2010

‘Ex-Serviceman’ status to boarded out recruits

This is related to the post on ECHS facilities to recruits.

Many boarded out recruits keep inquiring whether they are to be treated as ‘ex-servicemen’ or not.

The answer is in the positive. While the DoPT definition of ‘ex-serviceman’ clearly includes personnel in receipt of disability pension, the MoD has also clarified vide its OM No 12/I/2005/D dated 01 February 2006 that boarded out recruits in receipt of disability pension shall be treated as ex-servicemen for all practical purposes.

It may be recalled that a recruit released from service due to an attributable / aggravated cause is entitled to disability pension including service element under the provision of Regulation 181 of the Pension Regulations.

26 comments:

Sgt.S.Kanthiah said...

Sir,
It is a valuable information. But it is sad that a Recruit with disability pension , is not permitted to enroll his wife in the ECHS . He got married after discharge from service. A man with ESM status is eligible for all the facilities of an ESM , why this is not allowed. Part II are is taken and endorsement of family pension also (Joint notificatiion) done. When we represnted the case, the Central Organisation has informed us that , Married after discharge, the family is not entitled to become member of ECHS, Kindly verify and take up the case sir.
Thanking you.
Sgt.S.Kanthiah,
Chief Liaison Officer,
Exwel Trust, Tirunelveli-Dist, TN.

Maj Atri said...

Dear Maj Navdeep,
I did not opt for permanent commission after my initial 5 years of service. On release I was placed in medical Category A3 permanent and awarded a disability pension element of Rs 525/- for life. Kindly let me know if the service element should also had been added?? If yes then how much.

Rgds
Maj Narender Suraj Atri

Navdeep / Maj Navdeep Singh said...

Maj Atri, of course you are entitled to service element also. Even the disability element has been enhanced to Rs 5880 for 100% disability.

Kumar said...

Only the armed forces offer life long universal health benefits for a few months of service (which included only basic training). The recruit is boarded out only because his recovery process is likely to be beyond the permitted time duration. Previously, medical benefits included only treatment for the disability for which he was boarded out which was quite rational.
Why should government be responsible for treatment of a lung cancer of a 60 year ex-recruit smoker who had put in 2 months of training and was boarded out for stress fracture of tibia from which he had fully recovered by the end of 6 months from date of injury??? Why should the government be responsible for his wife and children's treatment too???
No wonder we have to wait in all those huge lines in ECHS polyclinics and MH as well.

Is there any end to entitlement benefits? Why do we equate ex-recruits (with a few months of training) to ex-servicemen who gave away best years of their lives to the Defence Forces?

A healthy debate is possible on this only if contrary opinions are also allowed.

auromitra said...

Dear Navdeep
Doing a great job.
Please confirm whether my son, GC Amit Mitra, an ex OTA cadet(GC 21197) in 2001 who was boarded out medically due to injury during training & granted 30 % disability pension by the govt, is an ESM in the light of the provision quoted by you.
He is already in receipt of canteen facilities vide Army HQ MT Dte(MT 5) letter,
If so, what action do I take in this regard now,
warm regards,
Brigadier Arobindo Mitra(Retd)
Omkar Apartments,
Third Floor, Flat No.9,
223, NSC Bose Road,
BANSDRONI,
Kolkata-700047, West Bengal,
Cell: 08974003611

augustlastrain said...

Dear Maj Navdeep,

First of all I must appreciate the fact that you made an effort to clarify and resolve various doubts/concerns regarding ex servicemen status.

I, Ex GC N Narula, number 21668 OTA, got boarded out on medical grounds with 20% disability granted for life. I did visit the office ( directorate of statistics n records), R K puram where I was categorically denied the ex servicemen status. They said that circular dated 01 feb 06 is only meant for "RECRUITS", i.e. those undergoing for NC/OC training and not meant for GCs.

While the argument was definitely not convincing, it was explained that since you have been awarded ex gratia you wont get it.

I request you to throw some light on this if possible. That could resolve my query and possibly doubts of those who do face this situation tomorrow.

Regards,
Nitanshu

kamaljit said...

i want to know that how many members in a family are able to get ex serviceman facility because my younger sister is now teacher of science and math in ssa and she got the job under the sc ex service man category. Can i am able to get the ex service man facility for my job

kamaljit said...

i want to know that how many members in a family are able to get ex serviceman facility because my younger sister is now teacher of science and math in ssa and she got the job under the sc ex service man category. Can i am able to get the ex service man facility for my job

ajay kumar said...

I myself AJAY KUMAR(8210334-N) was enrolled in IAF in X group technical on17th jun 2002 & while training i was medically boarded out for pulmonary tuberculosis on 25th aug 2004. in my discharge certificate I was categorized as non ex-service man & no facility of Ex-serviceman was provided like ECHS & canteen facility,except pension.
My Questions are –
1- Am I eligible to get Ex-serviceman facility?
2- Can I get age relaxation in govt job as Ex-serviceman?
3- When I was married after I was medically boarded out. Is my spouse is eligible for benefits as a family member of an Ex-serviceman?

Someshwar said...

nitanshu u r correct
there is lot of contradiction for ex-servicemen
as far as the status of ex gc is concerned i have clearified from Dopt through rti and they have clearly stated that ex gc are not treated as exservicemen for employment purpose
with regards
someshwar
ex gc ota ssc 81
09408530534

drswinderjit said...

sir,
i want to seek information regarding reservation rules for ex-serviceman dependent kindly suggest me a way
1 i am presently woring on contractual post umder NRHM againt reservation as ex-serviceman dependent
2;now pb govt launches regular pasts in the same dept after long wait of 20 years
now my an many others got in a problem as we applied for the regular posts dept denies to gave benifit as ex-serviceman dependant asking u had availd ur reservation now suggst us the way 21 postonly16 cand a out of wch 5 fresh rest lke me who applied for 2nd time

GAATHI said...

Dear Major Navdeep,
I am Lt Gaurav Tripathi, been boarded out on Psychiatric grounds which were not attributable to military service. May I know if I am entitled to claim a seat under the category of Ex-servicemen in various colleges and other organisations.
It would be very kind of you sir if you enlighten me with your views on this aspect.

Regards
Lt. Gaurav Tripathi

Asadha said...

Sir, I am an Ex. Recruit with disability pension. Our District Ex-servicemen board says that I cannot be given Ex-serviceman status for getting priority in job for my dependent(here my wife). They say the status has been scrapped recently. Can you shed some light on this sir, please.

Someshwar said...

as discussed by major navdeep sir about the letter dated 01 feb 2006 issued by mod regarding ex-servicemen status of ex-cadet/recruit boarded out on medical ground for all practical purpose. i would like to inform u that till date the said letter has not been notified by DOPT as a result of which no officer cadet or recruit boarded out on medical ground can get the benefit for employment. this is very sad and one of the example of red tapism. regarding this matter one recruit has filed case in ahmedabad high court.too

Someshwar said...

To all the Ex- Cadet boarded out on medical ground I would like to confirm you that Ministry of defence, vide their Office Memorandum No. 12/1/2005/D(Res) dated -1 st Feb., 2006 has conveyed that it has been decided with the approval of Hon'ble Raksha Mantri that such recruits who are boarded out/released on medical grounds and granted medical/disability pension, will also be covered under the category of Ex-servicemen for all practical purposes.
**Officer cadets boarded out of training academies will be treated as Ex-servicemen only for the purpose of employment in civil services.** This definition is available on the website of goa ex-servicemen welfare site. The said OM has not yet been notified by Department of personnel and training as a result of which neither ex-recruit nor officer cadet. those who want to get the said OM notified can put their grivences on pgportal.gov.in against the department of personel and training and to the president grivence cell at http://helpline.rb.nic.in
This will be quite helpful as such grivences are taken into notice as well as when such grivences on one issue will be received from many people it will certainly draw attention
someshwar
9408530534

epeneth said...

Sir,

I served the corps of Signals for a period of 1 yr 33 days and I was medically board out as Fits(nyd)without any disability pension even after second appeal, I get the canteen facilities, but whether can I get the facility for renewing my Two wheeler license fee please. I was discharged on 03 Sept 1980.

M Epeneth
Ex Rect

Ashwani guleria said...

Respected sir, Mera naam Ashwani guleria hai m 26 Dec,2003 ko army mechanised infantry se recruit medical board aaya hun mujhe abhi tak exservise men ki all facility mili hai job ko chod ke lekin family ka na to echs card bana hai na hi aur facility pls mujhe bare m batayen

Ankit Dev said...

respected sir,
I no.15619817-L, Ex.Recruit Dev Ankit Ravindrabhai. I join brigade of the guards dated:-04/01/2005 and Medical Board Out dated:-01/09/2006 and i received medical board pension per month 8303/-.but our Zilla sainik board,ahmedabad and Rajya sainik board,gujarat not issue Ex.serviceman identity card and CSD Canteen AFD-I Canteen not issue banifit and other state issue status Ex.serviceman identity card and CSD Canteen AFD-I Canteen also provided last 6 years and Rajya sainik board, gujarat & zilla saink board, ahmedabad said DOP&T not Notified Medical Board out Recruit status of Ex.Serviceman and issue of Identity card but other state issue already this facility.

So,Please guide me this matter.

Regards,

Army No.:-15619817-L
Ex-Recruit
Dev ANkit Ravindrabhai

ANKIT DEV said...

respected sir,
I no.15619817-L, Ex.Recruit Dev Ankit Ravindrabhai. I join brigade of the guards dated:-04/01/2005 and Medical Board Out dated:-01/09/2006 and i received medical board pension per month 8303/-.but our Zilla sainik board,ahmedabad and Rajya sainik board,gujarat not issue Ex.serviceman identity card and CSD Canteen AFD-I Canteen not issue banifit and other state issue status Ex.serviceman identity card and CSD Canteen AFD-I Canteen also provided last 6 years and Rajya sainik board, gujarat & zilla saink board, ahmedabad said DOP&T not Notified Medical Board out Recruit status of Ex.Serviceman and issue of Identity card but other state issue already this facility.

So,Please guide me this matter.

Regards,

Army No.:-15619817-L
Ex-Recruit
Dev ANkit Ravindrabhai

Anonymous said...

Respected Sir,

Greetings from Ex-Rect. Mer Valubhai Vajubhai.!

I am Ex-Rect. Mer Valubhai Vajubhai I was enrolled in Army AD Center Nasik Road Camp on Dated: 31/12/2001 at RR & D Bty with Army No.15776962W as a Recruit (Sol/Tech) but in the center Re-medical time I was medical boarded out from service by Army AD center under the authority of table annexed to army rule 13 (3) (iv) being invalided medical board out on dated 02/05/2002. Army AD center was released me from the center on dated 02/05/2002 that time I got one certificate whose name “INVALIDING FROM SERVICE: RECT” ,In the AD center before Discharged I was got some stipends per month and also after Discharged I was got some of Rs.8118/- from AD Center on Dated 01/08/2008 and some of Rs.1040/- from AGIF on dated 25/11/2009. but till date I am not getting Discharged book. this information is for your reference only that in the Gujarat many Ex-recruits getting all the facilities like PPF, Canteen, Ex-servicemen quota in civil service and some other facilities who given retired Ex-servicemen who recruit also medical board out from service under the Army Rule 13 (3) (iv) being medical boarded out as like me.
So kindly I requesting to you suggest me what can i do? i am eligible for the ppf and other facility of the army?
please give me your valuable reply.

Thanks & Regards,

Army no.15776962W
Ex-Recruit (sol/Tech)
Mer Valubhai Vajubhai

Anonymous said...

I am Ex-NDA and medically boarded out.

Is there any way I can avail medical benefits?

Ameen Anees said...

what is the duration of service for a territorial army personnel for him to be granted an ex- service man status please guide me on this

N MK said...

Respected sir,
I am D/42232 Ex GC Nidheesh Mohan Kandwal. 130 regular.
I got medically boarded out due to heavy spinal cord injury from the respective Indian Military Academy on 9 sept. 2011.. sir i am facing vast difficulties due to my spinal ache. i am preparing for various govt. entrance examinations, but my injury always act a hindrance to it. sir i request you with great gratitude to kindly tell me about the job opportunities and facilities provided for medically boarded out GC's.
sir i am in an immense disarray in context my future.. I am an MBA and MA (ECONOMICS)degree holder but due to training and injury i have lost my three years. sir with a humble gratitude i intensely require your guidance.

VIJAY said...



INFORMATION ABOUT IDENTITY CARD ISSUED BY ZILA SAINIK BOARDS

Respected Sir,
1. I wish to clear my few doubts about above mentioned subject

(a) I was enrolled in INDIAN AIR FORCE on 27 Sep 2006 and after seven years of service I got discharge from service on 29 Sep 13 without any pension.

(b) As I have served Indian Air Force for less than 15 years, I have not been issued with any PPO. Only Discharge certificate is issued to me.

(c) Now, as per instructions given on DGR’s site and in a book placed at Zila Sainik Board, Bikaner. It is clearly mentioned under heading “process for issue of identity card” that for issue of identity card either PPO or discharge certificate is to be produced.

(d) But then also Zila Sainik Board, Bikaner is telling that PPO is must for issue of identity card, and they refused to issue me the same.

2. In view of the above, I humbly request that please clarify the doubt about the issue of identity card to the personnel not issued with PPO. As identity card is must for person like me to prove his identity as an Ex-member of defence forces. Thus I request you to please guide me the right path, so that me & my family would keep pride and faith in defence services.




917528-N
Ex-CPL
VIJAY KUMAR MATORIA
Eltro fit

vaibhav said...

sir,
i am Ex cpl vaibhav gupta. i was discharged from Air Force on medical ground and disability pension is recommended for me, but as it will take around one year for pension to be approved, i will not get ex-servicemen benefits for this period of one years. i was issued a 'Medical Card' from unit and was told that i can get medical benefits on the basis of this card.Can i avail medical treatment for my parents who are dependent on me on this Medical Card.
Anybody can help?its urgent.

vinoth kannan said...

Respected sir ,
i am vinoth A.no 15724233y , i was discharged from indian army on medical ground (IMB) with disability pension is recommended but 2years completed after my discharge , i have not recieve any information about my disability pension. Even i did not get rejection letter also. If any suggestions for me please help me sir